Pension Plan Puppets: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Has Kentucky Improved Since the Non-Conference Season?

The Great Unknown

I don't know if I just relish the role of playing the devil's advocate or if I could be on to something here but I don't feel that the Leafs made the right move in firing JFJ and hiring Cliff Fletcher. I know I might be drawing the ire of all the regular readers and contributors of this site but I'm going to throw my two cents into the ring and let you guys tear it apart. In the very least, it will likely help me sleep better at night. Let's get it going then.

Star-divide

I know it is a big market and demands extra attention but I felt that the amount of media coverage over this whole debacle was a bit sensational and ridiculous. The media really pulled out all the stops on this one. I felt that parading guys like Bill Watters around and having them say the same things over and over was foolish. Why should I have to listen to what he thinks, to my recollection, didn't he get fired by the Leafs for poor performance. How is he allowed to critique anyone else? Does his getting fired make him an authority on losing your job at MLSE. Didn't the Leafs fire Cliff Fletcher once upon a time as well?

I found it interesting to hear the reaction of the players this morning. Most of all I enjoyed Wade Belak's comments the most. He is probably one of my favourite Leafs despite his lack of talent and contribution. He stated that he felt there were not many moves that Fletcher could make and that most of the team was under contract for the next few years. I know that there is more to be done than he would surmise but it does get one thinking about what moves can be made and can Cliff Fletcher really make that big of a splash in the next 35 days that he will be shaping the course of the team for the coming years. When I thought about it more I realized that Belak was probably right. Aside from trading all the assets for draft picks and prospects there is probably very little that can be done.

I can foresee the team trading Mats for a load of picks and prospects, maybe even a Darcy Tucker if all parties can be satisfied, or even the move we've all hoped for, dealing Raycroft (Don't get me wrong, I'm a big supporter but it's time). Outside of that is there really any moves that can or should be made. I hope they don't trade away the young assets. All this thought leads me to wonder if hiring Cliff Fletcher, a man who has been out of the game since the new CBA, was the right move. JFJ was around for the transition and although he didn't make the right moves and still operated with the throw money at the players mentality of the pre-lockout, he did still know the new system better and had operated in it for two years. I'm not saying that he was the best choice but I would still say that he's better than Cliff Fletcher. Personally, I think that I would have ridden out the year with JFJ, all the while searching for a replacement. I think that Cliff Fletcher while not necessarily the wrong choice is not the best choice and because of interim basis with no long lasting tenure, I feel that he is not going to be fully accountable for his decisions. If things start to go awry he can simply step back and leave the mess for the next guy to clean up. All in all, I'm worried about the team's future and would have stayed with the devil I know rather than one that I don't.

A final note goes out to Bobby Mac at TSN. He called this one right from the start and even narrowed down the window of the firing to 48 hours. He was very accurate for this whole affair and has moved up a notch in my book.

PensionPlanPuppets.com is a fan community that allows members to post their own thoughts and opinions on the Toronto Maple Leafs and hockey in general. These views and thoughts may not be shared by the editor of PensionPlanPuppets.com.

0 recs  |  Comment 2 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Great Start

Now that's a opening post! Don't worry about penning a contrarian viewpoint because we welcome it. And that is what the diaries are for, to express a well thought out opinion.

As for the opinion, I think Fletcher is the guy to take the Interim role. He has experience in Toronto and he has experience moving veterans for youth (the Sundin deal and the trading away Gilmour deal).

I was actually afraid that they would let JFJ ride out the year but they should have let him go in the summer. This way at least they don't have a lame duck GM in charge of another trade deadline.

I have confidence in Fletcher.

by PPP on Jan 23, 2008 9:24 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

Bobby Mac

is an Insider genius. He heads the short-list of industry professionals that you can trust.

Good post, not that I agree with it, but blows my short ones out of the water.

The Hat spoke about how Cliff was a lifer at hockey and I don't doubt that he has been sitting around getting ready for his next chance. He looked so ready during the press conference. I think he has some magic left in him.

by David Danforth on Jan 23, 2008 4:22 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog for the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Start posting about the Maple Leafs »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

800px-flag_of_new_brunswick
The Book of Rebuild, Chapter 35

Recent FanPosts

Dgb_small
Did Marc Crawford's son break the Lehtonen trade via twitter?
Ob_ax_190_1_small
Kessel vs. Malkin: A Graphical Comparison
Fml_copy_small
The top 5 reasons I'm glad I didn't trade those tickets for a used blender.
Buffalo_sabres_v_toronto_maple_leafs_3kqnv0wzt7fl_small
Leafs vs Devils February 5 (Photos)
Clipboard01_small
Can the Leafs still qualify for the Playoffs? Do I even want to know? I know you do!
Small
The Leafs need new jerseys...
Leafs_man_small
PPP Dictionary: "You're a Dick"
Axl_rose_01_small
Who had 'four days' in the pool?
Leafs_man_small
More submissions for the PPP dictionary!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

StatCounter

wordpress visitor


Chief Blogging Officers

Calvin_small PPP

59_small Chemmy

PPP's Princesses

Alfie2_small Mattblack

Dscn1755_small wrap around curl

Mr_hanky_small Karina

Don_t_panic_small SkinnyFish

Contributing Bloggers

Clockwork_orr_cropped_small mf37

Tester_small Greener

Hitchhiker_42_small 1967ers