Phil Kessel vs. the NHL's Top Scorers - A Statistcal Analysis

Editor's Note: clrkaitken's been working on some interesting calculations about Phil Kessel and his comparables in the NHL. The numbers paint quite the picture.

Long story short...

In the aftermath discussion of the announced Kessel trade, "say plan the parade one more time" mused about how Phil Kessel's season stacked up against other top scorers in the league last year.

Over the past few hours, I've pored over the stats of the top scoreres from the 2008-09 season, and created a huge spreadsheet that served to try and accurately compare Kessel's season, apples to apples, to those of the league's top guns.

Seeing how it's past midnight, and I'm barely coherent from the double-barrelled shotgun of the Kessel trade reaction and doing this for the past two hours, I'll put this up for now, and then tomorrow I'll post my findings and go into detail about how our new boy stacks up. The comparative players might put a new spin on the trade for some people.

First off, allow me to apologize for sleep and real-life getting in the way of me finishing this. Hopefully much like the Kessel deal itself, this will be worth it once it finally is ready to go.

After compiling all of the relevant statistics from, I've tried to determine who is a comparable offensive player to Phil Kessel. This was primarily based on three statistics:

G/A Ratio - A measure of the number of goals a player scored for every assist. For instance, Phil Kessel's G/A ratio was 1.5 last season. For every 3 goals, Kessel would register 2 assists.
GPG - A measure of the average number of goals a player scored in each game.
PPG - A measure of the average number of points a player scored in each game.

To be considered "comparable", a player needed to have a number that is within 25% of Kessel's statistics. 10 players had comparable numbers to Kessel for those three stats.

Jeff Carter, Eric Staal, Marian Hossa, Thomas Vanek, Dany Heatley, Patrick Marleau, Loui Erikkson, Johan Franzen, Jason Arnott, Alexander Frolov

First, let's put everyone on equal terms. Using the GPG and PPG for each individual, I've projected what we could expect their stats to look like if they all played 70 games, which is what Kessel played last season.

Kessel 70GP 34-26-60
Carter              39-33-72
Staal                34-30-64
Hossa             38-29-67
Vanek              38-23-61
Heatley            33-28-61
Marleau           35-30-65
Eriksson         31-23-54
Franzen           34-24-58
Arnott               36-25-61
Frolov              29-25-54

Based on 70 games, Kessel would have been outperformed by Carter, Staal, Hossa, and Marleau. He would have been superior to Eriksson and Frolov, and pretty much in-line with Vanek, Heatley, Franzen and Arnott  However, these statistics aren't entirely representative, because almost everybody played a significantly higher number of minutes than Kessel did. Kessel played about 16 and a half minutes a night, while most played 18 or 19, and some up to 21 minutes a night.

Let's factor in another statistic that I calculated from the information available, ATOI/G. The calculation determines the approximate amount of time a player is on the ice before scoring a goal. For instance, based on 16:33 minutes a night, and 70 games, and 36 goals, Kessel scored a goal every 32:11 of ice time. This figure is significantly better than all of the comparitave players (except Hossa & Vanek).Let`s adjust everybody`s 70 game statistics, to simulate that they all played an average of 16:33 a night, statistics that are exactly identical to Kessel`s.

Kessel 70GP 34-26-60
Carter              32-26-58
Staal                27-23-50
Hossa             35-28-63
Vanek              37-22-59
Heatley            27-24-51
Marleau           27-24-51
Eriksson         26-19-45
Franzen           31-22-53
Arnott               31-23-54
Frolov              24-21-45

Now, all of a sudden Kessel's production seems very favourable. If you take away some of the additional minutes these guys played, suddenly their production starts to pale in comparison to Kessel, and he's right on line with guys like Jeff Carter, Marian Hossa, and Tomas Vanek, people who are considered elite goal scorers in the league.

Now here's where the naysayers start to talk about "the Savard effect"; primarily, the fact that Phil Kessel's production was largely dependent on the quality of his teammates. So let's look at the Quality of Competition and Quality of Teammate statistics from for these players.

Kessel  QOC 0.014 QOT 0.225
Carter             0.039           0.039
Staal               0.053          (0.037)
Hossa            0.023           0.481
Vanek             0.016           0.032
Heatley           0.039          0.003
Marleau          0.018          0.334
Eriksson        0.044         (0.115)
Franzen          0.057         0.235
Arnott             (0.002)        0.132
Frolov             0.037          0.013

So, there may be a little bit of truth to the effect that Boston's great squad had on his numbers.But two people's numbers jumped out at me; Marelau and Hossa.

Patrick Marleau had a greater QOT, and a pretty comparable QOC. Given the same amount of ice time, we would have expected him to score 10 points less than Kessel. Marleau was also 29 last year, and making $6.3M.

Marian Hossa, however, played against stiffer competition, but was surrounded by immense talent in Detroit. If we project similar ice time to Kessel, his production would likely be consistent with Kessel's. He turned 30 last season, and Chicago has seen fit to pay him $7.9 million for the next seven years (cap hit being $5.275M because of the 12 year contract).

I'm not suggesting this is in any way conclusive, and it makes a ton of assumptions. But I think what I've managed to demonstrate is that the raw numbers for a lot of these guys are masked by the fact that they log pretty high minutes for a forward. Playing far less minutes, Kessel was a significantly more effecient player than all of these "elite" scorers. The other thing is that most of these players are already in their prime, while one could argue that at 21, Kessel hasn't even reached his yet.

If Kessel can click with one of our good young centres (Grabovski, Kadri, hell, maybe even Stajan) and match his breakout season, I think that $5.4 million might be a downright bargain.

Below, is the spreadsheet I compiled to do my initial analysis. 

Phil Kessel 70 36 24 60 1.50 0.514 0.857 16.55 32.18
Alex Ovechkin 79 56 54 110 1.04 0.709 1.392 23 32.45
Jeff Carter 82 46 38 84 1.21 0.561 1.024 20.57 36.67
Zach Parise 82 45 49 94 0.92 0.549 1.146 18.75 34.17
Ilya Kovalchuk 78 43 48 91 0.90 0.551 1.167 21.8 39.54
Rick Nash 78 40 39 79 1.03 0.513 1.013 21.15 41.24
Eric Staal 82 40 35 75 1.14 0.488 0.915 21.03 43.11
Marian Hossa 74 40 31 71 1.29 0.541 0.959 17.78 32.89
Thomas Vanek 73 40 24 64 1.67 0.548 0.877 17.18 31.35
Dany Heatley 82 39 33 72 1.18 0.476 0.878 20.1 42.26
Mike Cammalleri 81 39 43 82 0.91 0.481 1.012 17.55 36.45
Patrick Marleau 76 38 33 71 1.15 0.500 0.934 21.35 42.70
Loui Eriksson 82 36 27 63 1.33 0.439 0.768 19.82 45.15
Evgeni Malkin 82 35 78 113 0.45 0.427 1.378 22.52 52.76
Jarome Iginla 82 35 54 89 0.65 0.427 1.085 21.6 50.61
Jonathan Toews 82 34 35 69 0.97 0.415 0.841 18.62 44.91
Simon Gagne 79 34 40 74 0.85 0.430 0.937 19.02 44.19
Johan Franzen 71 34 25 59 1.36 0.479 0.831 18.1 37.80
Alex Semin 62 34 45 79 0.76 0.548 1.274 19.23 35.07
Brad Boyes 82 33 39 72 0.85 0.402 0.878 19.13 47.54
Sidney Crosby 77 33 70 103 0.47 0.429 1.338 21.93 51.17
Jason Arnott 65 33 24 57 1.38 0.508 0.877 18.9 37.23
Alexander Frolov 77 32 27 59 1.19 0.416 0.766 19.92 47.93
Pavel Datsyuk 81 32 65 97 0.49 0.395 1.198 19.2 48.60
Corey Perry 78 32 40 72 0.80 0.410 0.923 18.6 45.34
Jason Spezza 82 32 41 73 0.78 0.390 0.890 19.68 50.43
Shane Doan 82 31 42 73 0.74 0.378 0.890 20.23 53.51
Daniel Sedin 82 31 51 82 0.61 0.378 1.000 18.78 49.68
Patrick Elias 77 31 47 78 0.66 0.403 1.013 18.57 46.13 is a fan community that allows members to post their own thoughts and opinions on the Toronto Maple Leafs and hockey in general. These views and thoughts may not be shared by the editor of

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Pension Plan Puppets. You should read them.

Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Pension Plan Puppets. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.