Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Stan Van Gundy Fired As Head Coach Of The Magic

The drafting differences of East Side vs West Side

I understand TSN's point here when they're comparing the two teams, which is the noticeable discrepancy of draft picks accumulated from 2003 to 2011. Basically, the author illustrates that Toronto will have only drafted 16 players in the first three rounds of the draft since 2003, while Los Angeles will have drafted 38 players during the same time. Never mind, the author is being very presumptuous that both Los Angeles and Toronto will stay the course for both the 2010 and 2011 drafts, but this evaluation is only one aspect of how a team evaluates draft picks.

Star-divide

Despite Toronto's low draft pick numbers, the amount of games who have played with Toronto or with another NHL team doesn't make it as disastrous as the article indicates. The LA Kings have a bevy of drafted players, but about half of these players have yet to play in the NHL. Furthermore, the Leafs have made a marking, significant or not, in the rounds beyond the third. The numbers also don't add up, since the author doesn't consider getting back a first round pick to choose Luke Schenn as a wash either. Manipulating the data to prove one's point, despite being technically incorrect? Nah, that never happens!

In fact, since 2003, players drafted by the LA Kings beyond the third round have played in a total of 66 games with the Kings. The Maple Leafs in contrast have drafted players in rounds fourth and beyond who have played a total of 230 games so far with the Leafs. If you include games not with the Leafs, the total jumps to 294 games. In addition, the totals for the Leafs doesn't even include the games played by Viktor Stalberg and Carl Gunnarsson (17 and 14 games so far respectively).

Either way, I understand the study in contrast is an intriguing one to further emphasize the whole notion of Toronto failing in the rebuild through the draft. That can't be argued. But it's not as clearcut as analysts make it out to be, considering the context of both teams being far different when NHL hockey resumed after the lockout. One team made the playoffs for six straight seasons before badly miscalculating the team's overall makeup after the lockout. The other team out West missed the playoffs for two straight seasons immediately preceding the lockout, and are still seeking out their first berth since the 2001-2002 season.

PensionPlanPuppets.com is a fan community that allows members to post their own thoughts and opinions on the Toronto Maple Leafs and hockey in general. These views and thoughts may not be shared by the editor of PensionPlanPuppets.com.

Comment 5 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Pension Plan Puppets

A Good Night For Tanking

Apr 2012 by JP Nikota - 436 comments

CAST AWAY WILSON

Mar 2012 by JP Nikota - 1162 comments

Comments

Display:

Manipulating statistics in a way that misrepresents the truth in order to make your point?

No one does that, do they?

\sarcasm

"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones."

Albert Einstein

by Say *plan the parade one more time*... on Jan 27, 2010 4:00 PM EST reply actions  

Great post, I appreciate the effort that it took to bring those numbers together. I’m also surprised at the amount of work that went into that TSN piece, that isn’t something you see every day from a group with deadlines as stringent and, I hate to say it, little emphasis on factual work. Though the author makes a throwaway comment of Detroit making a living off of late-round picks, which I think has been debunked pretty well.

But I think I have to disagree with your conclusion, at the end of it all. The point of the article is that one team has had an emphasis on keeping their early round draft picks while the other has placed their emphasis on moving multiples of those picks for players, and now the teams are moving in opposite directions. That’s pretty clear cut. Even though the Leafs have found depth from their later round picks, it’s obvious that if there’s one thing this team needed from it’s picks it wasn’t simply depth NHLers.

While the team’s situations have obviously not been the same throughout the history surveyed, one can make the argument that in terms of laying the bedrock for a post-lockout environment one team did well and the other appears to have not learned it’s lesson. And even though the argument can be made that time has not told all yet, when you trade picks for roster players I’d say it’s easier to evaluate where a team is going to go sooner.

by koopa kid on Jan 28, 2010 5:47 AM EST reply actions  

Like you, I was surprised as well TSN allowed an article of this breadth considering their emphasis on breaking stories. I would love to see more of this, but I understand why that’s not always possible.


Even though the Leafs have found depth from their later round picks, it’s obvious that if there’s one thing this team needed from it’s picks it wasn’t simply depth NHLers.

Not after the lockout. The Leafs were coming off six straight playoff seasons. The team still had Mats Sundin in his prime. While hindsight allows the benefit of saying the Leafs should have been more prudent with their early draft picks, at the time JFJ and MLSE believed their time of opportunity wasn’t closed yet. The problem with the Leafs was it took them several unsuccessful attempts to find their goalie of the future after Ed Belfour’s demise mainly because of Mats Sundin. If he fell off the map just as the other veterans left over from the playoff years, I doubt even JFJ would trade early picks (something he vowed not to do when hired) for those goalies. I will relent, however, that this is JFJ we’re talking about, so my hypothetical point is probably moot.

And even though the argument can be made that time has not told all yet, when you trade picks for roster players I’d say it’s easier to evaluate where a team is going to go sooner.

As a predictive measure, of course. And I guess that was the point of the article. Clearly, the problem for the Leafs wasn’t necessarily trading away those early picks, but rather not replenishing some of those picks. Whether they obtained another second round pick or whatever, the Leafs stayed put. But again, for the picks the Leafs traded recently, they were for the purpose of young, potential high impact players. Luke Schenn, Phil Kessel, and even Andrew Raycroft, since he was only 26 years old (of suckage, but hear me out) didn’t fit the usual profile of trading early picks for old, washed out players. Simply looking at the numbers is fine. The Leafs traded away a lot of draft picks, and in this case, they mostly resulted in a net-loss.

But if the Leafs choose to trade early picks for young impact players and continue their late draft pick prowess, then the end result isn’t as horrid. Is it an ideal method? Time will tell.

Supporter of the Sergei Berezin "Give and Go" - You give me puck, then you go to hell

by bkblades on Jan 29, 2010 12:49 AM EST up reply actions  

Tolensky kicks ass, the only problems I have with his writing is he doesn’t do enough of it.

by lordosis on Jan 28, 2010 10:07 AM EST reply actions  

agreed.

his analysis of goal scoring vs age totally changed how i valued players.

by Death_By_Leafs on Jan 28, 2010 3:17 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Your best source for quality Toronto Maple Leafs news, rumours, analysis, stats and scores from the fan perspective.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Newman_small
PPP Salary cap Challenge - samspade
Small
PPP Salary Cap Challenge - DaSim85
Globeatar_small
How Much Should You Spend On A Top 4 D?
Phaneufkessel_small
TOI-weighted NHL Team Ages
48839cd14228986f0ad0d2e405f1_small
Casting Call
Petering_small
PPP Salary Cap Challenge - Self Destructive Zones
Globeatar_small
The Fancystats Exchange, Part 1
Or-wallpaper-1680x1050__1__small
PPP Salary Cap Challenge-BCapp #2
Lifeasaleaffan_small
PPP Salary Cap Challenge, lucc
Small
PPP Salary Cap Challenge, Hansmoleman

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

StatCounter

wordpress visitor


Chief Blogging Officers

Calvin_small PPP

Aen1_small Chemmy

PPP's Girlfriends

Don_t_panic_small SkinnyFish

Picture_1_small JP Nikota

Fg_small birky

Christian-hanson-wrecks-brian-o_1__small Bower Power