History #23 - The Leafs vs. the Habs

Back in December, an article appeared over at thehockeywriters.com that purported to be a comparison of Leaf and Hab fans.  In the end, it was just a thinly-veiled spin of the old "Habs have a 'winning tradition' and therefore the fans don't accept mediocrity" blather.

There was a moment of interest in the notion that the French/English dynamic in Montreal was somehow reflected in this fan experience, but that never seemed to get beyond the point that some Montreal players were, in fact, English.  At no point was it ever really shown that this was a) by design or b) relevant.

What really irked me was this:

If you go deeper into the statistical analysis using the annually updated "NHL Official Guide and Record Book", it’s easy to uncover the underlying reasons for the greater number of cheering opportunities that lucky Habs fans have enjoyed from the start. As of 2009 and in exactly the same number of games played in all-time NHL history (5,874), the Canadiens have scored 19,284 goals. Over the same all-time period, Toronto has scored 18,189 times. Not even close. The Canadiens have won 3,021 regular-season games, the Leafs 2,569, a significant difference. The Canadiens have had better goaltenders, as evidenced by the incomparably higher number of Vezinas in the trophy cabinet. They’ve had better defensemen, as indicated by the Canadiens’ ten Norris trophy wins compared to zero by the Leafs. In fact, they’ve had more star players in virtually every category.

Now, if you really get into the numbers, a lot of this comes off as absurd. 

The "not even close" goal total?  The difference between the two teams is 1095 goals.  Sounds like a lot, but that's taken over 91 seasons.  It works out to a difference of 12 goals per year.  If you prefer, it's the difference between a team that scores 3.29 goals per game and a team that "only" scores 3.10. 

The win difference works out to just less than five per season.  Now, five wins is ten points, even in Gary Bettman's NHL.  That's significant, isn't it? 

Well, yes and no.  Let's look a little further into it. 

The truth of the matter is that virtually the entire win discrepancy boils down to one factor:

Harold_ballard_medium

Seriously. 

The distinction between the Habs and the Leafs boils down to the fact that the Leafs got Harold and the Habs didn't.  When you compare the team histories and remove the Ballard era, the Leafs and Habs aren't just similar - they're clones.

Now, within the Ballard era, there are really two distinct phases.  In the '70s, the Habs were going bonkers while the Leafs were always fair-to-middling - mainly because they sold off most of their farm system in the late '60s  (hey, free money!) and then got perpetually mauled by the WHA because Harold wouldn't pay anyone.  In the 80's, the Habs faded to being quite good but never dynasty-quality, while the Leafs one-upped them by going straight into the toilet.

Beyond that, as I said, the two teams are virtual clones - at least in terms of their records.  The rest of it - the counts of Norris/Vezina trophies, etc. is really just the result of stylistic differences and in some cases, timing (you can't win trophies that don't exist yet).  I'll get to that later (the next history post, actually).

First, though, let's deal with the records.  I've broken it up into some different time periods.  The first two represent the first 50 years of NHL action, subdivided by the start of the Leaf era (1926-27) and ending, appropriately, with the 1967 Stanley Cup.

The Dawn of Time

1917-18 - 1925-26 (9 seasons)

 GP  W  L  T  OTL  PTS  PCT  Cups  Finals
 Toronto Arenas/St.Pats  226   112   109   5   0   229   0.507
 2   2 
 Montreal Canadiens  226   115   105   6   0   236   0.522  1   3 

1926-27 - 1966-67 (41 seasons)

 GP  W  L  T  OTL  PTS  PCT  Cups  Finals
 Toronto Maple Leafs  2388
1089  904  395  0   2573
 0.539  11
 19
 Montreal Canadiens 2388  1174 804  410  0   2758  0.577  12
 18

Add that all up and the Cup total is 14-13 Montreal (counting the Habs' pre-NHL win - otherwise it's 13 each).  Finals appearances are 21 apiece.  In 2614 games, Montreal has 88 extra wins and 6 extra ties.  Over 50 seasons, that's 1.76 extra wins per season.  A slight regular-season advantage, but the championships were a wash.


Pal Hal Reigns

1967-68 - 1978-79 (12 seasons)

 GP  W  L  T  OTL  PTS  PCT  Cups  Finals
 Toronto Maple Leafs  938  402  381  155  0   959  0.512  0 0
 Montreal Canadiens  938  587  196 155  0   1329  0.708
 8
 8

1979-80 - 1989-90 (11 seasons)

 GP  W  L  T  OTL  PTS  PCT  Cups  Finals
 Toronto Maple Leafs  880
 301
 481
 98
 0   700
 0.398
 0
 0
 Montreal Canadiens  880
 476  280
 124
 0   1076
 0.611 1  2



These are the Ballard years.  It's not perfectly clean as Harold didn't have full control until 1971, but he was making his influence felt as the sale of the farm system predates his full takeover.  I broke it down to show both the scope of the '70s Hab dynasty and the spectacular wonder that was the '80s Leafs.

During the Ballard era, the Habs won 360 more games than the Leafs did, tied an extra 26 and had 9 extra Cups in 10 extra Finals appearances.  Note - that win total is 80 percent (well, 79.6) of the total win discrepancy over the 92-year history of these teams. 

Thanks for the memories, Pal Hal. 

Post Hal

1990-91 - 2008-09 - (18 seasons)

 GP  W  L  T  OTL  PTS  PCT  Cups  Finals
 Toronto Maple Leafs  1442
 665
 586  130
 61
 1521
 0.527
 0 0
 Montreal Canadiens  1442  669  569
142
 62
 1542  0.535
1
 1

Since Pal Hal died, the Leafs and Habs are basically the same team.  Montreal has won four extra games in 18 seasons of play (12 if you count this wonderful season we're currently enjoying).  That one Cup in 1993, well, we all know that story.

The Montreal Canadiens managed to avoid a completely horrific owner and they were able to stretch their heyday an extra dozen years past the point where the Leafs' ended.  For that they are to be congratulated.  They also never managed to plumb the depths to which Harold led the Leafs.  Another factor that plays in a bit is that Montreal's worst decade was played under a 48-game schedule.  Toronto's was played in an 80-game schedule.  That skews its impact on the overall totals.

For most of the past two decades, though, the Habs have been exactly where Toronto has been.  There is no winning tradition any more - the dynasty years are 30 seasons gone.  There is just a team that trades on its past and suffers under the expectations of the present - just like Toronto.  How that manifests itself in the fan base is anyone's guess.

What I want to talk about in the next one of these is what I see as the real difference between Montreal and Toronto, particularly in their respective heydays.  It was a question not of substance, but of style.

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Pension Plan Puppets. You should read them.

Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Pension Plan Puppets. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9355_tracker