The centennials we're still not celebrating

100 years ago, the Toronto Blueshirts played their first season. Like most new teams, it involved a fair amount of losing, though not as much as the Tecumsehs, their roomates in the new Arena Gardens. The Blueshirts would go on to become extremely important, not just as the 1914 Cup winners, but because an entire league was founded just to get away from them. We never talk about this.

I think for the most part people are aware that the NHL is heading into a centennial year in 2017 (let's not play the semantic game of 100 seasons vs 99 seasons vs 100 elapsed years - it was fun in 2009 but ultimately a waste of time). Most people would also be aware that it will also be considered 100 years of Leafs hockey (once we add in the 10 they spent as the no-names, the Arenas and the St. Pats).

What keeps being forgotten (or at least left out of the discussion) is the fact that pro hockey in this city predates the NHL by about a dozen years. The team that existed here before 1917-18 is the very reason for the existence of the NHL and there were others before that. There were players who contributed great moments to this city that are never talked about, a championship most have never heard of and an owner so hated that the entire NHA packed up and left rather than deal with him (rather unfairly, in my opinion).

What's also irksome about the entire thing is that the story is actually really interesting - pro hockey was a total free-for-all and the history is rampant with liars and cheats and infighting and inter-league raids, player strikes and salary caps, lawsuits and swindles and all sorts of other goodies that we don't get to see these days (not in the same manner, anyway).

A while back, when PPP (the blog, not the person) was a lot smaller and I needed something to talk about in the summer, I wrote a series about this period. I had been reading a book called Deceptions and Doublecross - How the NHL Conquered Hockey and I used this as a starting point talk about the early years of Toronto hockey. I figured I'd be done in seven or eight posts. Twenty-two entries later, it was done. I still need to do the next series on the St. Pats. I hope it will be shorter.

I have to admit that it seems to me to be quite the shark jump to put up a link to posts from four years ago, but it beats rewriting them. :)

Besides, I think these are still things worth talking about and a story that still deserves telling. One hundred years ago - the 1912-13 season - we had the inaugural season of Toronto HC, better known as the Blueshirts. This forgotten team is arguably the most important in all of hockey as there would be no NHL without it. (There - that should draw out the haters. :) )

The history series:

History #1 - Revisionist History

History #2 - The Lay of the Land - Hockey before the NHA.

History #3 - The Way we Played - Hockey with Seven Players per Side

History #4 - Giving the Devils Their Due - the Sens and Wanderers

History #5 - Goodbye and Good Riddance - the Birth of the NHA

History #6 - Lest We Forget

History #7 - Snits and Giggles

History #8 - Ladies and Gentlemen - Yoooouuuuuurrrr Toronto Blueshirts!

History #9 - The Blueshirts - So Who WERE These Guys?

History #9a - The Blueshirts - So Who WERE These Guys? (Part II)

History #10 - the Tecumsehs (the not-Blueshirts)

History #10b - Things Fall Apart

History #11 - The Arrival of Eddie Livingstone

History #12 - Livvy buys a team - and a problem

History #13 - Feb 3, 1915 - when a loss is not just a loss

History #14 - Another name you should know - Corb Denneny

History #15 - 1914-15 - The rest of the season that was.

History #16 - Eddie buys a(nother) team

History #17 - Curiouser and curiouser

History #18 - 1916-17 - Where it really hits the fan

History #19 - Goodbye and (not particularly) good luck, Mr. Livingstone

History #20 - A "Temporary" New League is Born

History #21 - Endgame

History #22 - Some last thoughts on karma and other random things

One of the cool features of this was that the authors of Deceptions and Doublecross periodically wandered by to add their thoughts to what we were talking about. I say it a million times in the pieces, but go give this a read. It's worth the effort.

In This Article

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Pension Plan Puppets. You should read them.

Join Pension Plan Puppets

You must be a member of Pension Plan Puppets to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Pension Plan Puppets. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.