Okay, I'll start right off by saying this is a silly comparison. Martin Jones, newly minted Leaf, has really bad stopping pucks numbers and has for half a dozen years now.

Maple Leafs sign Martin Jones
As expected, the Maple Leafs have added some insurance in net.

But I wanted to explore the reasons why the Leafs signed Jones, beyond some of the classical justifications.

Oh, just before we get into it. It might be worth stating the classical reasons.

  1. Jones has been a reliable goalie to be in the net or on the bench for 30+ games his whole career.
  2. He's an NHL goalie (albeit at the bottom end) and hasn't yet been demoted to the AHL, even after signing low salary contracts.
  3. He's a bar in preseason for Joseph Woll to beat so he can justify being the backup. Jones needs to be seen next to Woll for this, not just be a waivers guess.

Okay, now to look at the various goalie statistics Money Puck graciously provides. I am not including Woll in this analysis because he simply hasn't played enough games (last season or in his career) to have any meaningful data. His .932 save percentage last year means nothing to me. Well, I guess it's not .832.

Last year, 25 goalies played in 41 games or more. That data set includes Samsonov in Toronto and Jones in Seattle.

Goals Saves Above Expected/60
Samsonov: 6th
Jones: 21st

Save Percentage Above Expected/60
Samsonov: 7th
Jones: 21st

So far, as expected. Relative to the goals they were expected to give up behind their respective defenses, Samsonov is coming out way ahead of Jones.

Let's look at shot locations to see what it says.

Low Danger SV% Above Expected
Samsonov: 24th
Jones: 7th

Medium Danger SV% Above Expected
Samsonov: 1st
Jones: 23rd

High Danger SV% Above Expected
Samsonov: 3rd
Jones: 23rd

Okay, interesting. Jones didn't give up any of the poor shots, and likely has some talent seeing through screens (as we'll see in a couple stats below). The struggles immediately show back up in the slot and in front of the net. Samsonov was excellent in those categories, but gave up stinkers from distances too often.

Now, we get into some of the more micro stats, to better understand what the Leafs see as similar strengths and differences between Samsonov and Jones.

Rebounds Above Expected Per Save
Samsonov: 18th
Jones: 1st

Puck Freezes Above Expected per Shot on Goal
Samsonov: 11th
Jones: 5th

Repeating the point about low danger shots, Jones does well to reduce rebounds in front and also freezes the puck (creating a D-zone faceoff) less than most of the eligible goalies. Samsonov is harmlessly average in these categories.

And after looking back on multiple years. The puck freezing and rebound limiting stats seem to be relatively consistent. Viewing Jones' shot location results just tells me to not read too much into them on a single goalie.

In conclusion, I think Jones has some skills. He wouldn't be in the league otherwise. He's also had to play around some pretty crappy defenses – Seattle's was bad, Philadelphia was pathetic before that, and San Jose in the depths of their decline – so that might not help with what happens when rebounds do come around.

In the end, it's hard to tell. I am comforted from the notion that Jones might be the Leafs backup/1B by his durability and how many games he can play a year.

Some of his microstats are useful, but only if they result in shots getting stopped. When that's not there, what else can you say. He's nice? Good hair? He looks like he should be good?

Various Leafs and Branches

2023 Top 25 Under 25: Brandon Lisowsky is 22nd
Lisowsky and Saskatoon put up the points for an eye-catching season in the WHL. What are his next steps as a leader on his team and looking ahead towards pro hockey?
2023 Top 25 Under 25: Dennis Hildeby is 23rd
Overlooked in multiple drafts prior, he was a good use of a late-round pick, but the difference in early career between him and Woll is marked. Woll, part of the UNTDP and a member of Team USA since the U17 team in 2015, was on everyone’s radar as a prospect, and Hildeby never was.
Hirvonen set to play in North America, eyes future with Maple Leafs
Roni Hirvonen got a taste of hockey in North America toward the end of last season, but even though the Toronto Maple Leafs center prospect did not get into a game for Toronto of the American Hockey League, the experience left the 21-year-old eagerly anticipating his first full season outside his na…
Will Matthews and Pettersson stay long-term? A look at how NHL stars decide to re-sign or go
What do franchise NHL players like Matthews and Pettersson consider besides money when deciding to commit long-term or not?
Kivlenieks goaltending camps keep memory of the late goalie alive
Latvian Hockey Federation introduced goalies age 10 and under to the sport this summer with help from the CBJ Foundation
Arizona Coyotes’ owner Alex Meruelo eyes Mesa, Arizona as potential future home for franchise | TSN
Arizona Coyotes owner Alex Meruelo has executed a letter of intent to purchase a parcel of land in Mesa, Arizona to be the potential spot for a sports arena and entertainment district for the franchise.