The Toronto Maple Leafs and Boston Bruins are two of the oldest surviving franchises from the NHL’s first decade, yet somehow they have only met fourteen times in the playoffs over the past 93 seasons. The majority of the series have gone in Toronto’s favour, but that is all in our grandparents’ past, as the Maple Leafs have not beaten the Bruins in a playoff series since the 1950s. Expansion hurts us all. That and passing on Bobby Orr.
1932-33: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins in five games - 3-2
The first time these two franchises faced off, the Maple Leafs took the five game semi-final series all the way to the limit, winning in game five. The season’s series was heavily in Boston’s favour, with the Maple Leafs going 1-4-1 against the Bruins. The most noteworthy game is game five, which went to triple overtime and is the second longest game in NHL history.
I’m going to take a minute and just ponder here why the Maple Leafs and Bruins were the only series in the 1933 postseason to play a best of five series versus a total goals series like every other series aside from the Stanley Cup Finals. NHL, what were you doing?
1934-35: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins in four games - 3-1
Two years later they met again, and the Bruins again won the season series 3-2-1. In the playoffs, however, the Maple Leafs beat the Bruins in four games this time around. The end result was the same however, with a Stanley Cup Final loss, this time to the Montreal Maroons. This would be the Maroons final Stanley Cup win.
This series featured three shutouts (2 Toronto, 1 Boston) and a double overtime win by Boston in game one.
1935-36: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins 8-6 total goals series
The Maple Leafs had the winning record vs the Bruins this time around, going 3-1-2 against Boston. To get into the playoffs the Maple Leafs had to play a two game total goal series against the Bruins. The Maple Leafs won this series 8-6, scoring eight goals against the Bruins at Boston Garden in game two.
The Maple Leafs would go on to defeat the New York Americans 2-1 in the semi-finals and go down 3-1 in the Stanley Cup Final against the Detroit Red Wings.
The Maple Leafs 8 goal game featured a hat trick by Charlie Conacher, the second goal being the game winner.
1937-38: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins 3-0 in best of five
The Leafs went back to having a losing record against the Bruins at 1-5-2 over the regular season. It wouldn’t matter though, as the Leafs swept the Bruins in three games in round one, but would lose 3-1 to the Chicago Black Hawks in the finals.
The sweep included one double overtime shutout and a 3-2 overtime win at the Boston Garden.
1938-39: Boston Bruins over Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 in the Stanley Cup Final
The Bruins would finally defeat the Maple Leafs when it mattered the most. The Maple Leafs beat the New York Americans (2-0) and the Detroit Red Wings (2-1) on their way to the finals, but couldn’t top Boston this time as the Bruins would win their second Stanley Cup in five games.
The Maple Leafs only win of the series came in overtime, after the Bruins rallied back from an early 2-0 deficit.
1940-41: Boston Bruins over Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3
Two playoff wins in a row for the Bruins, as they beat the Leafs in a tough seven game series in the semi-finals. The Bruins would move on to sweep the Detroit Red Wings in the finals for Stanley Cup #3.
Game seven was a close contest, tied 1-1 midway through the first period and then Mel Hill scored the winning goal for the Bruins with five minutes left to go.
1947-48: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins 4-1
The Maple Leafs would have to wait eight years for their revenge, and they would make quick work of the Bruins in the semi-finals before dispatching of the Red Wings in a four game sweep for their seventh Stanley Cup.
Game five was a big 5-1 win for the Leafs in Boston that saw Bill Barilko, Howie Meeker, Ted Kennedy, Garth Beosch, and Nick Metz score for Toronto.
1948-49: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins 4-1
A perfect repeat of the 1948 playoffs, the Leafs defeated the Bruins in five games and went on to sweep the Red Wings in the Cup final.
Game three was the big one again, which saw the Bruins win 5-4 in overtime at Maple Leaf Gardens. Woody Dumart scored the overtime goal with just under four minutes remaining, allowing the players to get to bed at a decent time for their day jobs.
1950-51: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins 4-1
Another five game series victory for the Leafs in the semi-finals and then they would go on to beat the Montreal Canadiens for the cup in another five game series.
The series winner was a big 6-0 win with Joe Klukay scoring three points (2G, 1A).
1958-59: Toronto Maple Leafs over Boston Bruins 4-3
After almost a decade apart from each other, they found a way to play again. In the semi-finals we have another Bruins defeat, this time the series went all the way to seven games, with the Leafs coming out on top. Unfortunately, the Maple Leafs would fall to the Montreal Canadiens in five games in the Stanley Cup Final.
This series had two overtime games and would be won in a 3-2 victory for Toronto by a goal with under 3 minutes left by Gary Ehman.
1968-69: Boston Bruins over Toronto Maple Leafs 4-0
A decade after their last meeting, the Maple Leafs lost their playoff mojo against the Bruins, being swept in the quarter-finals. Including two big blowouts of 10-0 and 7-0.
The goalies subjected to those blowouts were Johnny Bower and Bruce Gamble; they did alright otherwise in their careers, though.
1971-72: Boston Bruins over Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1
The first-overall Bruins finished the season 39 points (119) ahead of the Maple Leafs (80). What followed was an easy four wins - and one OT loss - over the Maple Leafs enroute to winning their fifth Stanley Cup over the New York Rangers.
The only winning goal for Toronto came in overtime and was scored by Jim Harrison.
1973-74: Boston Bruins over Toronto Maple Leafs 4-0
The Bruins again finished first overall in the NHL and used their might to again eliminate the Maple Leafs in the first round. The Bruins wouldn’t get a sixth Stanley Cup however, as they would fall to the Philadelphia Flyers in six games.
The Leafs made a game of it in game seven, losing 4-3 in overtime after Inge Hammarstrom tied the game with 1:47 left in the third period.
2013: Boston Bruins over Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3
We all know this series, as the final 15 minutes are ingrained in our minds. This is where the phrase ‘It was 4-1’ was born. It was supposed to be the highlight for the Brian Burke built Maple Leafs – though Burke himself was relieved of the General Manager position just days before the season began. However, one miracle comeback by the Bruins (that Bruins owner Jeremy Jacobs didn’t see; he left the game assuming that the Bruins were eliminated), and we were left stunned with the image of James Reimer lying face down in his crease. Most Leafs fans have made peace with the loss, and don’t care for a million recaps of the series despite what other, fancier, bloggers have said.
Fourteen series against the Bruins and the count goes 8-6 in the Maple Leafs favour. This year is the best chance the Leafs have had at winning another series against the Bruins, since they last did in 1959.
Game one starts tonight. Let’s go Leafs, series #15 is ours.