Toronto Maple Leafs
| Left Wing | Center | Right Wing |
| Richard Panik | Nazem Kadri | Phil Kessel |
| James van Riemsdyk | Tyler Bozak | David Clarkson |
| Leo Komarov | Peter Holland | Mike Santorelli |
| Josh Leivo | Sam Carrick | Matt Frattin |
| Left Defense | Right Defense |
| Dion Phaneuf | Cody Franson |
| Jake Gardiner | Stephane Robidas |
| Morgan Rielly | Roman Polak |
| Goaltenders |
| Jonathan Bernier |
| James Reimer |
New York Rangers
| Left Wing | Center | Right Wing |
| Rick Nash | Derick Brassard | Martin St. Louis |
| Chris Kreider | Derek Stepan | Mats Zuccarello |
| Carl Hagelin | Dominic Moore | Lee Stempniak |
| Tanner Glass | Kevin Hayes | Anthony Duclair |
| Left Defense | Right Defense |
| Marc Staal | Dan Girardi |
| Kevin Klein | Matt Hunwick |
| Conor Allen | Michael Kostka |
| Goaltenders |
| Cam Talbot |
| Henrik Lundqvist |
