At the beginning of the 2017-18 season, there were three question marks hovering around the Leafs roster. What was going to happen with James van Riemsdyk, Tyler Bozak, and Leo Komarov? The safest bet was that one of them was going. Odds are the man who doesn't like to wear a mouthguard.

That sentiment changed as the year went on and the Leafs made their way to historic numbers. We began to picture and accept a world without them. If you ask any fan or basement blogger, it’s almost a foregone conclusion.

So, why not add some darkness to our days and consider how would it look if they all re-signed in the summer?

Komarov is the easiest place to start. The 31-year-old had his worst year offensively since the 2012-13 season with 7 goals and 12 assists in 74 games. He also proved time and time again to be an ‘elite’ penalty killer per Mike Babcock.

However, the team looked to be more fluid when Komarov was demoted to the fourth line and looked it’s most lethal in the playoffs when Andreas Johnsson was in instead.

Bozak went from being the team’s ‘number one centre,’ to being propped up by Mitch Marner, and finally babysat by Connor Brown. All phases included seasons of little to no defence. He managed to hit 50 points for the first time in his career last season, again via Marner, but more often than not, watching Bozak in the defensive zone was more nerve-wracking than the final battles in Avengers: Infinity War.

It’s a simple story for JvR. There’s no discounting his specialty in scoring goals. If you set him up around the net on the power play, odds are your team is scoring. It may not justify the type of money he’ll command in free agency and this is where the darkness of the scenario continues.

The realistic nature of this scenario has JvR as the only recipient of a pay raise. Evander Kane helped his former divisional rival with that seven-year $49 million deal. Based on the raw production, it’s safe to say that Kane’s new cap-hit is JvR’s minimum.

Let’s say the Leafs give him $9 million (because you have to compete with other teams and NHL GMs lose their minds in July).

Komarov and Bozak make $2.95 and $4.5 million respectively. If Roman Polak can get $1.1 million after an OK season and a severe leg injury, Komarov signing a $1.5-1.75 million isn’t too crazy. Let’s go in the middle and say $1.62 million.

Bozak is the player of the three who will definitely get more than he deserves. JvR’s contract will be insane, but you can rationalize why he would make that much. Seeing as how he is a centre and managed to get 40 points, teams may be more willing to overlook his defensive shortcomings.

In the real world, it wouldn’t be surprising to see Bozak stay within that $4 million or even scratch the surface of 5. But this is fantasy land and because of that, $3 million.

The numbers could waver based on how stern Kyle Dubas is or how good their agents are. When the moment comes, the salaries could very well be far from the ones I’m coming up with. The moral of this very dark story is that the Leafs will be putting themselves in a massive rut by doing this.

It’s time to move on and focus on the new regime. So if you’re someone who is adamant on any of them coming back, be warned. And to those who already accepted this, sorry for making you cringe.

In Case You Missed It

Come On, Let’s Offer Sheet Somebody, It’ll Be Fun: A Case For The Leafs To Pursue Other Teams’ RFAs - Pension Plan Puppets
Offer sheets are a somewhat thing of the past that no teams want to use anymore because of the professional and 'personal' 'ramifications.' That being said, the Leafs should do it.

Around the Hockey World

You Train. You Fuel. You Push

Years into concussion lawsuit, Jacobs and other NHL owners deny knowledge of CTE - Article - TSN
*sigh* + *face palm*

Doug Armstrong on the Vegas Golden Knights: “I’m hooked on the story.” - St. Louis Game Time
Who isn't? It's safe to say the Vegas Golden Knights are the NHL's Game of Thrones book series.

Report: Isles F Kulemin signs in KHL - Article - TSN
We salute you former Leafs 30-goal scorer (that one time).

Looking into Conor Sheary and Carl Hagelin as Pens top trade candidates - PensBurgh
The H in the HBK line and the 1500th player to line up with Sidney Crosby could find themselves on the way out.

The Colorado Avalanche should throw a big offer sheet at restricted free agent Mark Stone - Mile High Hockey
Fulemin's reach has gone to the Avs.

Ray Ferraro on Lamoriello’s Impact on Tavares: ‘Doesn’t matter at all’ - Lighthouse Hockey
We can read between the lines here and say that John Tavares really likes to grow out his facial hair.

Alfredsson: 'We hope we get a new owner' - Article - TSN
Team #MelnykOut went above and beyond to get the point across.

This was sick...

This may have been even better.

Happy Tuesday Leafs fans!